Production mindset shifts

In animation production the animatic is gospel, but with AI in the mix the required mindset is much closer to live-action!
​
Animation production people have been taught one rule above all others: lock your animatic, then execute. Don't mess with the story once it's approved. That discipline is how you stay on budget when every single frame costs real money.
​
But AI production breaks that rule, due to both the limits and strengths of the tools.
​
First, sometimes the AI simply can't execute what's in your animatic. You prompted it clearly, the intent is right there, and it just… doesn't do it. No matter what your text prompt says or your start and end frames clearly indicate. So you adapt. You find a workaround, a different angle, a reframed shot. Other times, the AI hands you something nobody planned: a happy accident that's actually better than what was storyboarded!
​
This is going to feel completely backwards to many animation people. But it should feel familiar to anyone who's worked in live action.
​
In live action, once your set is built and your crew is there, the incremental cost of "one more take with a slightly different read" is tiny. You shoot options and want to get coverage. And then you actually build the film in the edit, working with the footage you got rather than rigidly executing a locked plan.
​
AI production works the same way. Rerolls are cheap. Generating another variation costs you minutes, not real money in the sense of putting it through an animation pipeline. So you start assembling in the edit the way a live action editor doe: "here's what came out of the tool", "what's the best version of this scene now"?
​
I wrote a while back that live action people moving into AI need to think more like animation people, since you ahve to storyboard everything, plan your shots, and not just wing it. That's still true. But the reverse is also true: animation people need to borrow the live action mindset of building the film in the edit. The animatic becomes your guide, not your contract. It is a bit like the saying attributed to Moltke the Elder: "No plan survives contact with the enemy, but nobody survives contact with the enemy without a plan.
​
The good news is where AI production actually has an edge over both worlds. Need pickups? Retakes? In live action, that means re-assembling a crew and re-building yout set. In traditional animation, it means sending shots back through the pipeline. In AI production, it might be a Tuesday afternoon.
​
The discipline of animation planning plus the flexibility of live action shooting is the production mindset that AI work requires. Neither side has the full playbook on its own!
​
By the way, if these musings spark any thoughts or questions just hit reply, I'd be happy to hear from you. Have a great day!

- Nick

Nick Dorra

Say hi 👋 on Linkedin​
🤝 Book a meeting via video or f2f to chat more